In a nutshell
There is no single best roof. A tiled warm roof is best if you want to use the room all year. Glass is best if you want light and a cheaper fix. Polycarbonate is best if the budget is tight.

On this page
Ask three roofers which roof is best and you may get three answers, usually the one each of them fits. This post sets out how the main options really compare, so you can decide what “best” means for your room.
Start with what is wrong now
Most people assume the best roof is the most expensive one. It isn’t always. The right roof is the one that fixes the problem you actually have, so it helps to name it first.
- “We can’t use it in summer or winter.” That is a heat problem, and a solid insulated roof is the change that deals with it.
- “It leaks and looks tired, but we like it.” That is a condition problem. New glass or polycarbonate will sort it for much less.
- “We just need it watertight for now.” That is a budget problem, and polycarbonate is the usual answer.
Once you know which of these is yours, the choice gets much easier.
The four main roofs compared
Here is how the options line up for a medium conservatory of about 3.5 × 3.5 m outside London and the South East. Use them for planning only; a roofer gives the real price. Ask whether a quote includes VAT.
| Roof | Typical price | Light | Comfort all year | Building Regulations application |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Polycarbonate | £2,500 to £4,000 (our estimate) | Good, softer | Limited | Ask your roofer |
| Glass | £3,500 to £5,000 | Best | Better with solar-control glass | Ask your roofer |
| Tiled warm roof | £8,000 to £12,000 | Lower, unless you add roof windows or a lantern | Best | Needed |
| Hybrid (solid with glazed panels) | Priced case by case | Good | Good | Needed |
The Federation of Master Builders, passing on Ideal Home’s figures, gives about £2,000 to £4,000 for polycarbonate, £3,000 to £5,000 for glass and £4,000 to £6,000 for a tiled roof. Tiled roofs on typical conservatories often come in higher than that once insulation, a ceiling and finishing are included, which is what the table shows.
Polycarbonate: best for a tight budget
Polycarbonate is light, cheap and quick to fit. New multiwall sheets will make an old roof look and perform better than it does now.
But it will not change how the room feels across the year, and rain on it is noticeable. It’s a sensible choice if you mainly use the conservatory in spring and autumn, or if you are fixing it up to sell.
Glass: best if you love the light
A modern glass roof is clearer and quieter in rain than polycarbonate. Solar-control glass reflects part of the sun’s heat, and self-cleaning coatings cut down on maintenance.
Glass is heavier than polycarbonate, though, so the roofer has to check the glazing bars and frame first. And again, it will not make the room as warm in winter as a solid roof.
Tiled warm roof: best for a room you use every day
If the aim is a room you can sit in in January and July, this is the one. A warm roof wraps insulation around the rafters and gives you a plastered ceiling, so the conservatory feels much more like part of the house.
Expect to pay two to three times what glass would cost. It also needs a Building Regulations application, because LABC and councils such as Carlisle explain that a conservatory with a solid roof no longer counts as exempt. Some lightweight roof systems carry LABC Assured certification, which makes that approval simpler.
Hybrid roofs: a middle path
A hybrid roof is mostly solid with glazed sections, or a solid roof with a lantern in the middle. You keep some sky while gaining most of the comfort of a solid roof. Prices vary with how much of the roof is glazed, so ask for a written figure, and the same Building Regulations application applies.
A worked example
Picture a south-facing Edwardian, about 3.5 × 3.5 m, in a Midlands semi. The owners can’t sit in it from June to August and it is too cold from November to March.
- New glass at around £3,500 to £5,000 would stop the leaks and look better, but they would still lose the room for half the year.
- A tiled warm roof at around £8,000 to £12,000, plus the council’s Building Control fee, would give them a room they use all year.
For them, the tiled roof is the better buy, even at more than twice the price. For a couple who use a north-facing conservatory as a plant room, glass would be the obvious pick.
So which is best?
The best roof is the one that solves your problem at a price you are comfortable with. If you want to see the numbers for your own size, the conservatory roof replacement cost calculator puts polycarbonate, glass and tiled side by side. When you have narrowed it down, a roofer who has looked at your frame can tell you what it will really take.